Riddle Me This…

So the teachers unions are in Wisconsin saying that the current fiscal mess there is not their fault but rather the fault of Wall Street.  That’s a point I generally agree with.  But then their vanguard proposals for reform – eg “peer review” and Randi Weingarten’s evaluation reform proposal last week – basically follow the same underlying approaches that got us into the fiscal mess, namely largely unchecked self-regulation.  Is education unique or are we ignoring some hard-learned lessons from other sectors?

3 Replies to “Riddle Me This…”

  1. If the mess isn’t their fault – then why would the teachers’ unions reforms do anything about the fiscal mess?

    It’s not the cause – it won’t be the solution.

    The teachers are damned if they do and damned if they don’t.

  2. Educators are very heavily regulated. Can you imagine the outcry were Wall Street subject to the same degree of control by elected officials as the education system?

    The choice is not between the current proposals for reform and zero oversight and regulation. The choice is between the current proposals and the existing and already substantial oversight and regulation.

    It is a fabrication to suggest that the education system is ‘self-regulated’ the way Wall Street is, and that the proposed reforms would improve, rather than erode, the existing system of oversight and regulation.

  3. Educators are very heavily regulated. Can you imagine the outcry were Wall Street subject to the same degree of control by elected officials as the education system?

    I can only assume that financial regulation is over your head. There is probably no sector of the economy that is subject to more regulation (from the CFTC, the SEC, etc.) than the financial sector.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.